SPOT A Teaching Guide — CRJ-900 CQ (Manual-Verified)
Nov 22, 2026 · @Chad Emery · Verified revision of the Nov 22 guide
Built from the Otter transcript of a CQ SPOT A pre-brief taught Nov 16, 2026. All of it is paraphrased. Every item that used to carry a [verify] tag has been checked against the project manuals. The page numbers come from the page headers and footers in the manual text, not from estimates.
Sources used (project copies)
| Manual | Revision / date |
|---|---|
| CRJ 900 QRH | Rev. 7, 01/30/2025 (eff. 07/01/2025) |
| CRJ 900 Emergency Checklist Card (EC) | Rev. 5 (eff. 07/02/2025) |
| CRJ 700/900 CFM | Rev. 12 TR 26-02 (eff. 09/08/2026) |
| FOM | Rev. 40, 07/29/2026 |
| CRJ 700/900 Systems Manual (Sys) | Rev. 6, 10/19/2026 |
| CRJ-900 ODH | Rev. 11 TR 25-01 (eff. 07/01/2025) |
| QSp1–QSp4 (SIROS captures) | Standards dated 1/10/2025. Cited by PDF page and task number. The text is OCR, so a few symbols (≤, ±) may have dropped out. |
Not in the project: the SPOT A lesson guide, the sim script, approach charts (SLC/LGA/JFK), and the slide deck. Anything that depends on those is marked Not found below.
Legend: ✅ Confirmed · ✏️ Corrected · ❓ Not found in project manuals · (technique) = instructor technique, not a manual requirement · [unclear] = audio still unresolved · ⚠️ = see Conflicts & Judgment Calls (Section 7)
1. Lesson overview
Lesson: CQ SPOT A (Special Purpose Operational Training) is a training/proficiency event that comes before the MV and LOE. SPOT B covers mostly the same maneuvers. Per the instructor, the differences are an arrival into MSP, a bounced-landing rejected landing, and a planned ditching from altitude. ❓ This comes from the brief only; the SPOT B lesson guide isn't in the project.
Objectives: Specific technical and CRM objectives are built into scenarios. SPOT allows direct instruction: you can freeze, coach, repeat, and debrief inside the sim. Several QSp tasks used today list TTP as the CQ strategy and FFS as the CQ medium (e.g., QSp3 PDF p. 36, Task 9.6.1; p. 47, Task 9.3.2).
Completion: Fly to the qualification standards, and repeat anything that's out of standards. If time runs out, the crew still goes on to the MV and LOE, but has to finish SPOT before flying the line. ❓ The completion rule wasn't found in the project manuals (it would be in the lesson guide or CQUM).
Format: ~60–90 min brief (this one ran ~72 min) → 4 hr sim with frequent seat swaps and a ~15 min break after about 1:15–1:20 (sometimes two breaks) → ~5 min debrief, since most debriefing happens in the sim.
| Brief segment | Transcript time | ~Minutes |
|---|---|---|
| Intro, SPOT format, standards, core comps | 0:00–5:00 | 5 |
| Unreliable airspeed (videos, memory items, QRH walk) | 5:00–30:35 | 25 |
| Stalls / stick pusher | 30:35–43:50 | 13 |
| Upsets | 43:50–47:00 | 4 |
| Terrain escape (SLC) | 47:00–52:20 | 5 |
| Emergency descent | 52:20–57:30 | 5 |
| Windshear | 57:30–1:02:00 | 5 |
| Contaminated runway + rejected landing | 1:02:00–1:04:20 | 2 |
| Ditching drill | 1:04:30–1:09:40 | 5 |
| Sim logistics | 1:09:40–1:11:50 | 2 |
Sim flow (as briefed): Hold short RWY 22 (LGA) with all checklists done → ~3 takeoffs each, alternating, with a freeze and reset after each climbout → air work and scenario events. Some events are flown by only one pilot (the captain had fewer). ❓ Event order and PF assignments aren't verifiable. The SPOT A lesson guide and sim script aren't in the project. Upload the sim script to fill this in.
2. Brief: what to cover, in order
- Set expectations. Cover SPOT A vs B, the ~1 hr brief, 4 hr sim, lots of seat swaps (not the old 2-hr-each MT format), in-sim debriefs, and a short final debrief. Confirm the MV time.
- SPOT definition and standards. Explain direct instruction: you'll freeze, coach, and offer repeats. Repeats are the crew's choice unless something's out of standards. Show the qual standards and the completion rule.
- Core competencies. These aren't the focus today, but you'll stop and discuss anything that stands out. ✏️ Have the crew skim FOM Ch. 8, "Core Competencies," pp. 8-168 to 8-171 (eight competencies, starting with Application of Procedures and Regulations) before the LOE. The qualification standards aren't in the FOM. They live in the QSp/SIROS (see the QSp cites under each event).
- Unreliable airspeed. The biggest block, about 25 min. Video first, then the ADC-failure comparison, memory items, the ISI discussion, a level-off scenario, and the QRH 13-10 walkthrough (see 3.1).
- Stalls and stick pusher (3.2).
- Upsets: definitions, then the nose-high and nose-low setups (3.3).
- Terrain escape at SLC (3.4).
- Emergency descent (3.5).
- Windshear on takeoff (3.6).
- Contaminated-runway landing (3.7) and rejected landing (3.8).
- Ditching / forced landing imminent (3.9).
- Tow bar slide [unclear]: something about writing up a tow bar issue and having maintenance look at it. ❓ Not found in the project manuals. Check the slide deck.
- Sim logistics.
- Either pilot may fly first. Start holding short RWY 22 with checklists done; the departure brief can be as short as they like.
- Weather is given verbally. It's a paperless flight, and everything you set up is legal. It's not a legality test.
- No headsets. Broadcast "in the blind" when told to contact departure or tower.
- Approach briefs can be abbreviated. There are no RTOs or V1 cuts today.
- Seatbelts on. Break after about 1:15. Ask for a break anytime.
- Show the evacuation procedure for the newer sim once you're in it.
3. Event-by-event breakdown
3.1 Unreliable airspeed (UAS)
Setup
- Happens at altitude, flown to a level-off with Table A, then a descent to about 12,000 ft with Table C. There's no arrival or approach on this one. The starting altitude wasn't stated. ❓ Confirm the scenario in the sim script.
- The PM uses either the Emergency Card or the QRH. ✅ Both are acceptable: the EC "UNRELIABLE AIRSPEED IN-FLIGHT" block repeats the boxed QRH memory items and points to QRH 13-10 (EC Rev 5, back side; QRH 13-11).
- QS: QSp3 PDF p. 40, Task 9.5.2 "Perform Manually Controlled Loss of Reliable Airspeed Procedure." Contingencies are ADC failure or pitot/static blockage. Maneuver standards:
- Correctly identifies the erroneous indications and verbally announces the discrepancy.
- Maintains or reestablishes the energy state with emphasis on pitch and thrust.
- Calls for and accomplishes the non-normal procedure, at minimum through verifying pitch and thrust settings for the current phase of flight.
Brief it like this
- Show the UAS video (shot in our sim) first. Frame it: "This crew has never seen UAS. They're reacting to what their instruments tell them." Tell them to watch the FMA when the overspeed clacker starts.
- Debrief the video with questions: What did you see? Why did he pull the power back? What changed in the FMA, and why?
- ✏️ Corrected answer (Sys 4-32, "Over-speed Protection and Warning"): In VS or PTCH mode during descent, an overspeed makes the AFCS revert automatically to IAS/MACH mode. The speed bug syncs to VMO/MMO – 5 kt and the airplane slowly pitches up to capture it. The mode flashes amber and the clacker sounds while in the overspeed, then turns green once out of it. In ALT or ALTS the clacker sounds but the airplane does not leave altitude, so the pilot has to reduce speed manually. The manual mentions no "short delay."
- Then the crew believes the overspeed, pulls power, extends the boards, stalls, recovers without power, believes the overspeed again, and gets a pusher.
- Show the ADC-failure clip. Ask: What does an ADC failure look like? Expect "red X's" (that's Garmin).
- ✅ On the CRJ, red air data flags replace the airspeed, altitude or vertical speed display when that ADC data is invalid (Sys 23-17, "Air Data Flags").
- ✅ ADC failure has its own checklist, QRH 11-10 "Air Data Computer Failure."
- ⚠️ But QRH 11-10 Note 2 sends you to UAS 13-10 if the pitch/thrust/noise picture doesn't match or no reliable airspeed side can be determined. QSp Task 9.5.2 also lists ADC failure as a UAS contingency.
- ⚠️ The instructor said the UAS notes "never mention those flags." Not quite: QRH 13-10 Note 2 lists EFIS COMP MON with amber IAS flag and EFIS COMP INOP with red IAS flag as no-crew-action messages. Those are comparator flags, not the air-data failure flags.
- Memory items. Have the FO fill in the blanks on the slide. ✅ Exact wording (QRH 13-11 box; EC Rev 5):
- Autopilot ........ Disconnect
- Flight Directors ........ Deselect
- Use ISI for pitch reference
- If initial take-off climb or go-around is required: Pitch/N1 ........ 10 degrees/TOGA from SL to 15,000 ft; 5 degrees/CLB above 15,000 ft
- Aircraft configuration ........ At clean-up altitude, Gear UP / FLAPS 0
- Airplane altitude ........ Maintain lowest safe altitude or higher
- CAUTION: RESPECT STALL WARNING/STICK SHAKER
- Discuss the memory items:
- Why go to the ISI? ✅ The QRH requires it on AHRS aircraft. Step: "For AHRS equipped aircraft: Set and monitor pitch and roll using ISI. For IRS equipped aircraft: use PFD" (QRH 13-11). Caution 4: "For AHRS equipped aircraft ISI must be used for pitch reference" (QRH 13-11).
- The instructor's reason (ADC–AHRS cross-talk can corrupt pitch in a turn) isn't stated in the QRH. Partly supported: Sys 23-24 says the AHRS sensor data is "combined with ADC and heading information" in the AHRS computers. The "in a turn" part is still his explanation only.
- The ISI is small and hard to read. (technique) Cross-check the ISI against the PFD; if they agree, fly the PFD. ⚠️ This conflicts with QRH 13-11 Caution 4 on AHRS aircraft (Section 7, #1).
- ✅ The memory-item pitch and power numbers are for initial take-off climb or go-around (the QRH 13-11 box condition). At altitude they'll keep the airplane climbing, so think about leveling off.
- Clean up any configuration and hold the lowest safe altitude or higher. ❓ The claim that the SLC MSA can force a climb to about 18,000 needs the charts, which aren't in the project. Respect the shaker, then QRH 13-10.
- Sim/aircraft quirks to warn about:
- ❓ In some sims and mods, the FD won't turn off in the overspeed; they can push it 30 times and it stays on. Not in the manuals. Treat it as a sim/fleet note.
- ✅ [unclear resolved] It's OK to silence the clacker early. QRH 13-12 Note 6: "Select the affected AUDIO WARNING switch to DISABLE if overspeed warning sounds." Otter's "DCUs" are the AUDIO WARNING DISABLE switch-lights (DCU 1 / DCU 2) on the copilot's side console (Sys 13-18). Disabling one DCU hands aurals to the other; disabling all DCUs disables all EICAS aurals, but not EGPWS or TCAS.
- (technique) Descend out of the clacker range to get modes and the autopilot back. ⚠️ QRH 13-11 Caution 1: DO NOT USE ANY FD/AUTOPILOT SPEED MODE, and Tables B and C repeat it.
- Scenario discussion (no wrong answers): NY–JAX, climbing through FL200 in heavy ice, and the pitot tube blocks while static still works. What does the airspeed do? It acts like an altimeter: it rises in the climb and falls in the descent. You break out at FL230 cleared to FL360, clear skies. Level off or keep climbing? Leveling off is probably best; descending is also an option. QRH 13-12 adds: "Leave current environmental conditions if they are considered to be a reason for unreliable airspeed."
- Leveling at 25,000: what pitch and N1 would you set? Let them guess first. (technique) The instructor's level-off numbers are ~1° pitch, 73–85% N1 depending on weight.
- He backs them up from Table A: at 75,000 lb, FL150–350 is about 1° and 70–83% N1. ✅ Confirmed (text-layer caveat). Table A (QRH 13-15) at 75,000 lb reads about 1.0° / ~70% N1 at 15,000 (cruise row), ~1.0° / ~78% at 25,000, and ~1.0° / ~82% at 35,000.
- The table's text layer is scrambled, so check these numbers against the printed page before teaching them.
QRH 13-10 walkthrough (Unreliable Airspeed In-flight, QRH Ch. 13, pp. 13-10 to 13-19)
- Biggest trap: crews jump to the boxes on the right. Start with the indication bullets to confirm you're in the right checklist. ✅ The indications are listed on QRH 13-10:
- Pitch attitude, thrust setting or external noise not consistent with indicated airspeed.
- Loss of multiple airspeed indication.
- Multiple airspeed indications remain constant regardless of pitch or thrust changes.
- Airspeed difference between PFDs >10 KIAS and/or >15 KIAS between any PFD and the standby airspeed/ISI, with no reliable source determinable.
- In the sim: once the airplane is roughly flying, freeze. Role reversal: the FO pulls out the QRH and calls each bullet "applies / doesn't apply / not sure." If none apply, you're in the wrong checklist; one or two should apply.
- ✅ "Autopilot may not be available" is QRH 13-10 Note 1. In practice it has always worked.
- ✅ "No crew action" for the associated messages (QRH 13-10 Note 2; 13-12 Note 2): EFIS COMP MON (amber IAS flag), EFIS COMP INOP (red IAS flag), STALL FAIL, MACH TRIM, RUD LIMITER; status RUD LIMIT FAULT, L/R FADEC FAULT 2. Don't chase them.
- ✅ Steps after the memory items (QRH 13-11 to 13-14):
1. AHRS: set/monitor pitch and roll on the ISI. IRS: use the PFD.
2. At desired altitude: Pitch/N1 per Table A. Stall PTCT, Pusher (either left or right) — OFF. Flight Director — PTCH/ROLL or HDG modes.
3. Autopilot — engage if available. Leave the conditions causing it. LH/RH COWL A/I and WING A/I as required.
4. Evaluate sources: AIR DATA source selector — NORM. Compare both PFDs and the ISI to the expected speed range from Table A.
- At least one reliable source? → Confirm NORM, monitor that source with caution, set pitch/N1 from the tables.
- None? → Disregard airspeed and fly the tables.
- Caution: the AIR DATA selector must stay in NORM. 5. Land at the nearest suitable airport. At [1] Descent, review the unreliable systems: GPWS, windshear detection, flap overspeed, automatic passenger signs. Increase actual landing distance ×1.25 (without two reversers and/or wet/contaminated) or ×1.20 (two reversers, dry). 6. Flap caution: FLAPS 0→30 in level flight; select FLAPS 45 at the start of final descent. Plan a long final.
- ✅ Other notes that matter (QRH 13-12):
- Trend vector, ground speed and FMS time/fuel may be unreliable.
- ILS/LOC/VOR deviation is reliable.
- Disengage MACH TRIM if the stab moves erratically.
- Altitude, Mode C and TCAS may be off by up to 600 ft.
- RTL limits may be wrong for the phase of flight, so avoid excessive rudder.
- Tables (enter at current altitude and weight; ignore the technique notes at the top for now):
- ✅ A (13-15): level flight, flaps 0. The usual target. Pitch can be adjusted ±1.5° in 0.5° steps; adjust the expected speed range when pitch changes.
- ✏️ B (13-16): climb, flaps 0, SL to 35,000 ft (TOGA low, CLB higher). It's used for any climb, not just "above 15,000." The 15,000-ft breakpoint is in the memory items (10°/TOGA vs 5°/CLB). Caution: no climb above 35,000 ft above 75,000 lb; use FD in PITCH mode only.
- ✅ C (13-17): descent at idle, roughly –2° to –3.5°. If anti-ice is needed, hold a minimum of 75% N2, adding +0.5° pitch per +5% N1.
- ✅ D (13-18): approach level flight by configuration (Flaps 8 gear up, 20 gear up, 30 gear down, 45 gear down).
- ✅ E (13-19): Flaps 45, gear down, 3° glideslope. Near sea level at 75,000 lb it's ~1.0° / ~61.6% N1 (text-layer caveat), with an expected speed of VREF ±10. Don't change N1; fly the glidepath with pitch.
- The tables are fluid. Pick the one that fits the situation (ATC climb, descent to VMC, etc.).
- Troubleshooting with expected airspeed: after setting pitch and power, compare each airspeed against the table's expected range. ✅ Table A shows 250–290 KIAS for the mid-altitude rows, including FL250 (text-layer caveat). Example: the captain shows 310, the FO 340, the ISI 280, so the ISI is likely the good one. QRH 13-13 caution: treat a source as reliable only if it agrees with pitch/thrust/table range and responds correctly to pitch and thrust changes.
- Cleanup items to point out:
- ✅ Stall PTCT pusher OFF: either left or right (QRH 13-11; Sys 9-36: either switch OFF disables the pusher).
- FD to PTCH/ROLL or HDG; if not in overspeed, IAS will be locked. Autopilot on if available.
- How do you get pitch mode? ✏️ Clarified (Sys 4-19/4-21): rolling the VS pitch wheel selects PTCH when the FD is on, unless in GS or VS mode. PTCH is also the default when no other vertical mode is active. Reselecting an active mode's FCP button cancels it. So "press VS" engages VS; press it again to cancel and default to PTCH, or just roll the pitch wheel.
- How much per pitch-wheel click? ✅ ½ degree per click (Sys 4-21; 4-41).
- Expect trial and error.
- Last notes: ✅ EGPWS and windshear detection are unreliable with UAS (QRH 13-14). Pick an airport without terrain or convective weather. Also, QRH 13-11 Caution 3: "Select the longest runway available with minimum crosswind and turbulence."
- Sim quirk: low on an ILS during UAS, the sim can give a windshear warning and pitch up. That's expected given the unreliable windshear detection (QRH 13-14), so disregard it. ❓ The specific sim behavior isn't in the manuals; it used to get written up as a sim fault.
Teaching points
- It will be confusing and they'll make errors. That's expected.
- Priority: memory items → airplane flying → QRH → a table, as fast as possible → then come back and clean up. This matches the QS minimum: verify pitch and thrust for the phase of flight (QSp Task 9.5.2).
Watch for
- Believing the false overspeed and pulling power or extending boards.
- Calling an ADC failure (red flags) UAS, or the reverse: staying in QRH 11-10 when no reliable source exists.
- Staying on the memory-item numbers at altitude and climbing into the clacker.
- Diving into the QRH boxes before confirming the indications.
- Using any FD/AP SPEED mode (QRH 13-11 Caution 1).
3.2 Stalls and stick pusher
Setup
- Impending stalls ("first indication" means the same thing) plus stick-pusher training.
- One stall low (LGA area, near sea level) and one high. The brief said below 5,000 ft and FL350. ✅ QS (QSp3 PDF p. 43, Task 9.4.3 Full Stall/Stick Pusher Training) lists entry altitudes of about 5,000 ft AGL and FL300. OCR may have dropped a ≤/≥ symbol, so FL350 fits if the standard reads "FL300 or above." Confirm in SIROS.
- Freeze before the full-pusher event to give tips.
- QS:
- Task 9.4.2 Stall Recovery Procedure (QSp3 PDF p. 44): contingencies include AP on/off, takeoff/clean/approach configurations, level flight and turns, and "recovery without thrust application (demonstration)."
- Task 9.4.3 Full Stall/Stick Pusher (p. 43): allow the pusher to reduce AoA; the pilot does not counter the pusher force, even at low altitude.
Brief it like this
- Ask: What are the first indications of a stall?
- ✅ CFM: buffet or stick shaker (CFM 7-123: "at the first indication of stall (buffet or stick shaker)"). Buffet isn't felt down low.
- ✅ System behavior (not a CFM "indication"): at high AoA the SPS activates CONT ignition, the shaker, and AP disconnect (Sys 9-36). At shaker AoA the FADEC energizes both igniters and CONT IGNITION posts (Sys 22-22).
- Low or decaying airspeed is a situational cue.
- Have them read the full-stall indications silently, then highlight the pusher. In the sim the pusher always comes before any full-stall behavior. ✅ CFM 7-125 list: stall warning, buffeting (could be heavy), lack of pitch authority, lack of roll control, inability to arrest descent rate.
- Ask: What do you hear and see with the pusher? Crews often say a "stall" voice. ✅ It's a warbler, plus STALL switch-lights on the glareshield flashing red (Sys 9-36; Sys 13-13 aural list: "Warbler — Stall").
- The pusher can be stopped by pressing and holding AP/SP DISC, and it rearms when released.
- It can be disabled with either STALL PTCT PUSHER switch OFF; both must be ON for it to fire (Sys 9-36).
- If AoA rises faster than 1°/s, the trip point is lowered (Sys 9-36).
- Story worth telling: a crew once disabled the pusher. They got porpoising of ±20°, then severe buffet, wing and tail stall, 8,000 fpm down, and couldn't recover. The point: don't get to a full stall; let the pusher work. ✅ Ties to the CFM 7-125 deep-stall description (T-tail, tail in the wing/nacelle wake).
- ✅ Procedure (CFM 7-124, Table 7-31):
- Initiate, PF: hold the column firmly and disconnect the autopilot. Simultaneously, reduce AoA with nose-down elevator until buffet and stick shaker stop, and apply adequate thrust, as required. If ground contact is imminent, use ALL available thrust.
- Continue, PF: roll to and maintain wings level; confirm spoilers stowed; accept an altitude loss while accelerating; if flaps/slats or gear are extended, don't change configuration during the recovery.
- Complete, PF: at the first indication of increased performance (airspeed and altitude), adjust configuration as desired, return to the appropriate altitude and airspeed, and re-engage the AP if desired.
- PM throughout: monitor altitude and airspeed, verify all required actions and call out omissions, and call out any trend toward terrain contact.
- CFM 7-123 NOTE: Do not use flight director commands during the recovery.
- Brief addition (not in the CFM table): use the radar altimeter down low.
- Ask: What's "adequate thrust"? There's no single right answer. Let them reason through it, then give the tips.
Technique tips (instructor's, not published)
- Low altitude: less thrust is better. With tail-mounted engines, APR/TOGA spools up, the nose drops, and the airplane is trimmed for level flight, so the crew loses more altitude than needed. (technique) About the climb detent, or roughly the 12 o'clock position, is plenty. ⚠️ This is bounded by CFM 7-124: ALL available thrust if ground contact is imminent (Section 7, #6).
- After recovery, what speed before you pull up? ❓ Nothing published. Around V2/VREF+20 and a normal flap schedule is reasonable. Some crews brief 200 kt.
- (technique) Once flying, think go-around: TOGA, speed mode, AP when desired. ✅ The CFM says no FD during the recovery (CFM 7-123). Recovery is complete at the first indication of increased performance (CFM 7-124), so FD/TOGA use after that doesn't conflict.
- Once "increased performance" is met, cleanup can continue even if the airplane sinks again. QS: "a secondary stall warning is acceptable as long as the angle of attack is promptly reduced and the airplane's limitations are not exceeded" (QSp Task 9.4.2).
- High altitude: be patient. (technique) Nose 5–10° below the horizon, trim, trim, trim (the AP was trimming for level flight), let it accelerate to about 280 kt, then very slow back pressure. 250 kt works only with a very gentle pull. Expect 4,000–6,000 ft of altitude loss, which is fine at FL350. ✅ Consistent with CFM 7-126: above ~20,000 ft the airplane is thrust-limited, altitude must be traded for airspeed, and the altitude loss is greater. The 280 kt and 4,000–6,000 ft figures are technique.
- Ask: What's normal descent speed? ✅ Mach 0.74 / 290 kt above 10,000 ft (CFM 7-31; climb "Normal" is also 290/M0.74, CFM 7-28). Use it to anchor the target speed.
- (technique) PM to ATC: say "upset" rather than "stall" on the radio. ❓ Not in the manuals. QS: declare an emergency if necessary, but don't delay the recovery for a clearance (Task 9.4.2).
- Context: under the old Mesaba standard you could not lose more than ±100 ft. ✅ Today accepting altitude loss is the standard. CFM 7-125: "emphasis has shifted from a recovery with minimum loss of altitude to reducing the angle of attack." QS: "positive recovery from the stall takes precedence over minimizing altitude loss" (Tasks 9.4.2/9.4.3).
Watch for
- APR/TOGA down low, then the nose pitches 10° down and too much altitude is lost.
- At altitude, pulling at 250 kt, which brings a second shaker or pusher.
- Not trimming.
- Fighting the pusher (QS Task 9.4.3: the pilot does not counter the pusher force).
- Cyclical or oscillating control inputs (QS Task 9.4.2).
3.3 Upsets
Setup
- First upset is a demo: slow flight at altitude, with the instructor working the thrust to discuss FADEC, airspeed, and "airspeed inappropriate for conditions."
- Then a nose-high and a nose-low. The nose-low is about 125° bank, 20° nose down, close to inverted. ❓ The setup values come from the sim and can't be verified.
- The upset program takes about 30 s to load. Use the freeze to review the picture and talk through the recovery.
- QS: Task 9.5.3 Nose High (QSp3 PDF p. 39) and Task 9.5.4 Nose Low (p. 38). Contingencies are maneuver-based or scenario-based (unannounced) upsets, in IMC or VMC. Standards:
- Promptly recognizes and confirms the deviation.
- Recovers without exceeding aircraft limitations.
- If stalled, recovers from the stall first.
- Declares if necessary, but doesn't delay the recovery.
- Avoids excessive pitch trim or rudder.
- Completes within the acceptable training envelope, then confirms flight path, automation and energy state.
Brief it like this
- Have the FO fill in the upset definitions. ✅ CFM 7-92: unintentionally exceeding pitch >25° nose up, pitch >10° nose down, bank >45°, or, within those parameters, airspeed inappropriate for the conditions.
- Stress reacting immediately. Beat the startle factor. Don't ask why are we here. Nose down, airplane flying, then talk to ATC. (technique) Treating it "as if it were a memory item" is framing: CFM 7-92 says the sequence is guidance and "a series of options." The QS does require prompt recognition and recovery.
- ✅ Nose-high (CFM 7-93):
- Disconnect the AP (expect a large out-of-trim).
- Pitch: up to full nose-down elevator, with nose-down trim to counter high stick forces. If that isn't enough, roll to get a nose-down pitch rate (normally no more than about 60° bank).
- Thrust as required.
- Roll the shortest direction to wings level (unload to improve roll).
- Recover to a slightly nose-low attitude when airspeed is sufficiently increasing.
- Avoid a stall from premature recovery or excessive G.
- ✅ Nose-low (CFM 7-95):
- Disconnect the AP.
- Recover from stall if required (it can be stalled at low pitch).
- Roll the shortest direction to wings level with full aileron/spoileron if needed. Don't increase positive G or use nose-up elevator or trim until approaching wings level. Past 90° of bank, unloading may feel like "pushing."
- Thrust and drag as required (spoilers if fast).
- Recover by increasing pitch slowly to avoid a secondary stall or over-G.
- Ask Why keep slight forward pressure? You're near or past critical AoA, and pulling while still banked gives an accelerated stall. Unload, then roll. ✅ CFM 7-97 (Inverted): roll toward upright (sky pointer) with slight forward pressure, neutralize the column as bank approaches 90°, and increase back pressure once bank is less than 60°.
- G limits: the tablet records G; they can't feel G in the sim. ✅ CFM 2-3, Maneuvering Limit Load Factors: flaps up –1.0 g to +2.5 g; flaps down 0.0 g to +2.0 g. Tell them you'll call it out loud ("2.2… 2.4… 2.5") as they approach the limit.
- ✅ PM (CFM 7-94/7-96): monitor airspeed and attitude throughout and VERBALIZE any continued deviation. The PF will have tunnel vision. Inverted, the PM calls attitude, airspeed and altitude and calls out omissions (CFM 7-97).
- ✅ Warnings (CFM 7-92/7-96): excessive pitch trim or rudder can aggravate an upset. Never make aggressive side-to-side rudder inputs.
Watch for
- Pulling before rolling wings level on the nose-low.
- Over-G on the pull-out (and remember the flaps-down limit is +2.0 g).
- Heavy rudder or trim use (a QS standard).
3.4 Terrain escape (SLC)
Setup
- SLC, field elevation about 4,200 ft, ILS 17. A mountain range sits about 5 nm off the airport. ❓ SLC elevation and the ILS 17 setup need the charts, which aren't in the project.
- Reposition onto a dogleg base: heading 090, 6,000 ft, ~200 kt, "vectors ILS 17." The track flies through the localizer, and ATC goes silent. ❓ This is sim-script setup.
- Leave it visual. The terrain gets very close before any alert.
- QS: Task 9.3.2 EGPWS Warning Maneuver (QSp3 PDF p. 47) and Task 9.3.1 Respond to EGPWS Caution (p. 48).
Brief it like this
- Ask: "Caution terrain" is just a caution. What do you do? ✅ The escape maneuver isn't required. CFM 7-108, EGPWS Caution: PF corrects the flight path or the aircraft configuration.
- Real world: turn toward the flat terrain near the airport; in the sim, fly straight ahead (it's set up as a game). ⚠️ The CFM maneuver has no turn: "simultaneously roll wings level" (Section 7, #4). (technique) On the caution: AP off, get ready to go around. It will almost certainly turn into the warning before thrust is up.
- Ask: What's the escape maneuver? ✅ CFM 7-106, EGPWS Warning Maneuver:
- PF: disconnect the AP. Aggressively apply maximum thrust. Simultaneously roll wings level and rotate to an initial 15°. Retract spoilers. If terrain remains a threat, continue rotation up to the stick shaker or initial buffet. When clear, slowly decrease pitch and accelerate.
- PM: assure maximum thrust (all available if ground contact is imminent). Verify actions and call omissions. Don't change gear or flaps until terrain separation is assured. Monitor RA for sustained or increasing separation. Monitor VS and altitude (radio altitude for terrain, baro for MSA). Call out any trend toward terrain contact.
- Pitch rate about 3–4°/s. Faster produces shaker from acceleration (CFM 7-106; QS Task 9.3.2).
- Do not use flight director commands (CFM 7-107). Ignoring or turning off the FD matches the manual.
- Flight at intermittent stick shaker may be required (CFM 7-107; QS).
- Exception: in daylight VMC with positive visual verification that no hazard exists before the warning, it may be treated as cautionary (CFM 7-107; QS Task 9.3.2).
- PM: watch the map and call altitudes and radar altimeter readings. ❓ ATC will give an MSA of about 13,000–14,000 (sim script/charts).
- If the RA unwinds fast ("1800, 1500, 1400, 1200…"), pitch up more, like in windshear. ✅ Matches CFM 7-106: continue rotation to shaker or initial buffet if terrain remains a threat. Crews have cleared terrain by 50 ft.
- Discussion question with no clear answer: Visual, with a peak ahead and a valley to the side, do you turn? A turn loads the wing and risks an accelerated stall. Let the pilot make the call. ⚠️ See Section 7, #4.
- A note on the slide applies only to "Sim 2" [unclear which note]. ❓ Not in the manuals. Terrain displays don't show until you unfreeze (sim).
Watch for
- Slow, timid thrust application.
- Following the FD.
- PM not calling the radar altimeter.
- Changing configuration before terrain separation is assured.
3.5 Emergency descent (rapid decompression)
Setup
- About FL350. Freeze first: take out the masks, wipe them down, review how they work, set them aside.
- Unfreeze. After about 30 s: a bang, then the sound of air rushing out.
- Sim limitation: the cabin climbs at only about 4,000 fpm, not the near-instant spike of a real hole. The crew sees CABIN ALT go amber, then red. ❓ The sim behavior can't be verified, but the amber caution / red warning sequence matches Sys 3-32.
- QS: QSp3 PDF p. 36, Task 9.6.1 Perform Emergency Descent. Standards: completes the applicable memory items, exercises appropriate emergency authority, stays within standard parameters or justifies deviations, and completes the applicable non-normal checklist(s).
Brief it like this
- Ask: What's the difference between the cabin differential-pressure and cabin altitude messages?
- ✅ DIFF PRESS (red) = differential pressure ≥8.6 psid (Sys 3-21, 3-32).
- ✅ CABIN ALT (red) = cabin altitude ≥10,000 ft (Sys 3-21, 3-32).
- Both come with the aural "CABIN PRESSURE" (Sys 3-21, 3-32).
- ✏️ The 8.7 psi figure is the CFM 2-20 maximum relief differential pressure limitation. The warning posts at 8.6 (Sys); see Section 7, #8.
- Ask: When does CABIN ALT go caution, then warning? ✅ Caution (amber) at 8,500–9,999 ft; warning (red) above 10,000 ft (Sys 3-32; also Sys 3-21 "≥8,500" / "≥10,000"). At 8,500 ft cabin the controllers also turn on NO SMOKING/FASTEN SEAT BELT (Sys 3-22). Pax masks auto-deploy at 14,000 ±300 ft cabin (Sys 3-21).
- Point: grabbing the mask on the aural is fine. Don't automatically start an emergency descent if it isn't needed (e.g., a DIFF PRESS at night in IMC). ✅ Supported:
- CFM 7-118: don masks and establish communication, then "verify cabin pressure is uncontrollable, and if so, begin descent."
- QRH 7-9 (DIFF PRESS): try MAN pressurization first; descend if control isn't regained.
- Today the bang makes it obvious, so masks on and emergency descent is fine.
- Ask the PF: How will you use the FCP and thrust to get it down? ✅ CFM 7-120, Rapid (Emergency) Descent Procedure:
- Both don O2 at 100% and establish comms. Captain calls "RAPID DESCENT."
- PF: Passenger signs ON. FCP: set lower altitude, engage SPEED mode, verify DES mode. Thrust IDLE. Flight spoilers EXTEND. Don't exceed the speed at which damage occurred, and minimize maneuvering loads.
- PM: contact ATC; request lowest safe altitude or 10,000 ft, whichever is higher.
- At level-off: speed as appropriate, spoilers RETRACT.
- CFM 7-118: AP use is recommended. Gear normally up. PM checks the lowest safe altitude, notifies ATC, and gets an altimeter setting. PM calls 2,000 ft and 1,000 ft above level-off. Level at the lowest safe altitude or 10,000 ft, whichever is higher. In turbulence, slow to turbulent-air penetration speed.
- QS Task 9.6.1: if structural damage isn't suspected, PF sets airspeed to VMO/MMO.
- (technique) Crews often spin the altitude selector all the way down without verifying. It's acceptable either way. ⚠️ The CFM level-off target is LSA or 10,000 ft, whichever is higher, with PM calls at 2,000/1,000 above level-off. A selector spun to the bottom removes the ALTS capture backstop (Section 7, #9).
- Then: memory items → Emergency Card or QRH (read-do). ✅ Exact memory items (EC Rev 5 "CABIN ALT or Emergency Descent"; QRH 7-7):
- Oxygen masks ........ Don, set to 100%
- Crew communication ........ Establish
- PASS SIGNS switches (both) ........ ON
- Descent ........ Initiate to 10,000 or lowest safe altitude
- Thrust levers ........ IDLE
- FLIGHT SPOILER lever ........ MAX
- QRH 7-7 continues:
- PASS OXY — Confirm and ON if CABIN ALT is approaching 14,000 ft.
- Structural damage suspected? No → don't exceed VMO/MMO. Yes → don't exceed the speed at which damage occurred, and minimize maneuvering loads.
- Then the door/hatch and repressurization branches (QRH 7-8).
- Remind them when they can take the masks off. ✅ QRH 7-7: "At a safe altitude and at or below 10,000 feet: Oxygen and masks — As required." Setting masks to N reduces consumption (QRH 7-8 Note 1). Masks get set aside and wiped again afterward.
- The QRH asks "structural damage suspected?" Today it's obvious.
- ✅ [unclear resolved] "alpha valve" = CPAM (cabin pressure acquisition module). The CFM Rapid (Emergency) Descent Profile note (CFM 7-119, Fig. 7-11): if CPAM indications are limited to about 14,250 ±750 ft, assume no structural damage; CPAM indications higher than 15,000 ft indicate probable pressure-vessel damage. The system basis: the control panel microprocessor limits cabin altitude to 14,500 ±500 ft (Sys 3-21, 3-26). So the instructor's "cabin holds ~14,000–15,000 → probably minor" is consistent with the CFM.
3.6 Windshear (takeoff, LGA)
Setup
- Windshear on takeoff, airborne in this lesson. Expect a caution that goes straight to the red warning. (SPOT B may do it on arrival. ❓ Not verifiable.) ✅ CFM 7-100 WARNING: "Be prepared for the WINDSHEAR Caution to be followed by the WINDSHEAR warning."
- QS:
- Task 9.1.4 Windshear Escape Maneuver (QSp4 PDF p. 3): contingencies include takeoff/climb and approach, recoverable and unrecoverable scenarios.
- Task 9.1.1 Windshear During the Takeoff Roll (p. 6).
- Task 9.1.2 Windshear Caution During Takeoff (p. 5).
Brief it like this
- Use a whiteboard runway with V1 = 130. Ask: Will you get a windshear caution or warning on the ground? ✅ No.
- The system is active between 10 and 1,500 ft radio altitude (CFM 7-98; Sys 16-51, Mode 7: takeoff 10→1,500 ft RA, approach 1,500→10 ft RA).
- CFM 7-100 WARNING: an encounter on the runway won't activate the system, so close monitoring of the airspeed trend during the takeoff roll is crucial.
- QS Task 9.1.1: PM calls out any significant variations.
- (technique) In the RTO brief, call it "windshear" rather than "airspeed stagnation" to avoid confusion.
- ✅ Ask: Windshear before V1? Reject (CFM 7-100).
- ✅ Airspeed stuck at 133, past V1? Set maximum thrust and follow the Windshear Escape Maneuver (CFM 7-100).
- ✅ How far down the runway before you rotate? Rotation shall commence no later than 2,000 ft before the end of the runway, even if below VR. Higher than normal stick force may be needed (CFM 7-100; QS Task 9.1.1).
- Ask: Walk me through the warning escape. ✅ CFM 7-102, Table 7-25:
- PF: disconnect AP. Press either TO/GA switch. Aggressively apply maximum thrust. Simultaneously roll wings level and rotate toward the FD guidance (TO/WS or GA/WS) if available, or an initial 15° if unavailable. Follow FD TO/GA guidance. Retract spoilers.
- PM: assure maximum thrust. Verify actions and call omissions. Advise when windshear guidance is activated. Don't change flap or gear until windshear is no longer a factor. Monitor VS and altitude. Call out any trend toward terrain, descending flight path, or significant airspeed changes.
- Don't try to regain lost airspeed until windshear is no longer a factor.
- So 15° is only for an unavailable FD, as the instructor said. ⚠️ The QSp 9.1.4 performance statement says "rotate toward an initial pitch attitude of 15°" (Section 7, #3).
- Indications (CFM 7-98): brief siren + "WINDSHEAR, WINDSHEAR, WINDSHEAR", red WINDSHEAR message, AMI on both PFDs, TO/WS in the FMA if the active vertical mode was TO (otherwise GA/WS). The AP disconnects within 2 s (CFM 7-99).
- Ask: What's the PLI ("eyebrow") for? ✅ [unclear resolved] The CRJ term is AMI, the Alpha Margin Indicator. Otter was right; "PLI" is the generic name.
- The AMI position is the maximum pitch attitude before stick shaker (Sys 23-37). It's coincident with stick shaker initiation (CFM 7-103), and it's displayed for a minimum of 60 s (Sys 23-37).
- The FD escape guidance may command pitch up to but not exceeding the AMI (CFM 7-103).
- If the PM calls a descent ("400, 300, 200"), pitch through the FD up to the AMI, where the shaker is, and ride in and out of the shaker. ⚠️ The CFM says "Stick shaker must be respected. Reduce pitch as required to stop shaker" (CFM 7-103) (Section 7, #2).
- ✏️ Warning removal: the warning indications are removed at 1,550 ft, with guidance staying up to an additional 8 s if still in active windshear, and you may still be in shear (CFM 7-98). Delay cleanup, take a breath.
- ✅ Then (CFM 7-102): when clear of windshear (AMI removed) and the vertical path is under control, accomplish the Go-Around Procedure. Post-windshear: set thrust and pitch for the phase of flight, configure, re-establish automation, make a windshear PIREP to ATC, and complete the After Takeoff checklist (QS Task 9.1.4 also requires notifying ATC).
Watch for
- Cleaning up as soon as the warning clears.
- Not using the full pitch available when sinking (up to the AMI).
- Chasing lost airspeed.
- PM not announcing that windshear guidance is active.
3.7 Contaminated-runway landing
Setup
- It's 15°C on the ground (the instructor admits it's an odd scenario). ILS RWY 22, RwyCC 3, crosswind within limits.
- Weather is given verbally. There's no trick; it's just an approach and landing on a contaminated runway.
- QS: QSp4 PDF pp. 28–29, Task 7.1.3 Landing on a Slippery or Contaminated Runway. Standards:
- Airspeed ±5 kt.
- Touchdown on centerline (between the mains) at the appropriate speed and pitch.
- Within the touchdown zone.
- Correct use of reversers, brakes and spoilers.
- Timely go-around if it can't be done within tolerance.
- From the performance statement:
- Thrust reduced slowly to reach VREF by 50 ft AGL.
- Flare between 30 and 20 ft AGL.
- If directional control is lost, reverse to idle (forward idle if necessary).
- PM calls "90 KNOTS", and the reversers reach the idle detent by 60 kt.
Brief it like this
- Ask: Max crosswind for RwyCC 3? ✅ 20 kt for the CRJ-900. That's the CFM 2-13 Company limitation ("Runway Condition Code is 3": 20) and the ODH RCAM chart (ODH Ch. 10, RCAM page preceding 10-2: RCC 3 "20 kts (900)"). RCC 2 or 1 is 15 kt, and wet is 27 kt (CFM 2-13).
- The slide cuts off the table, so point them to the ODH. Looking it up is fine.
- Landing distance: ODH 10-5 (RCC 3 actual landing distance); add 37.5% for factored distance (ODH 10-5 considerations).
3.8 Rejected landing
Setup
- On approach, ATC calls a go-around at low altitude, or something appears on the runway. (The bounced-landing version is SPOT B.)
- QS: QSp4 PDF p. 17, Task 7.5.1 Perform Rejected Landing. The contingency is a go-around below 50 ft. Standards:
- Timely decision.
- Appropriate thrust and pitch for the desired performance.
- Positive rate of climb and desired airspeed ±5 kt.
- Ground track/heading/course appropriate or as specified by ATC.
Brief it like this
- They should have time to react. Fly a normal missed approach. If the wheels touch, still fly the normal missed-approach profile. ✅ CFM 7-89 (and QS Task 7.5.1): set go-around thrust, hold the normal landing attitude or slightly higher, don't change configuration until accelerating above VREF and climbing through a safe height, then continue the go-around.
- ✅ Two Engine Go-Around callouts (CFM 7-77/7-78):
- PF: TOGA, set thrust, rotate toward the FD bars, "GO-AROUND, SET THRUST" (PM-initiated: state the reason, then "GO-AROUND").
- "FLAPS 8" (or 20; 20 is required with reduced VREF).
- PM: "POSITIVE RATE" → PF: "GEAR UP."
- At V2+10–15: "SPEED MODE," then "HDG MODE"/"NAV MODE."
- 600 ft AGL minimum: "AUTOPILOT ON" as required.
- At flap retraction altitude (normally 1,000 ft AFE): 200 KIAS or VT, whichever is higher, flaps per schedule, "CLIMB THRUST."
- CFM 7-88: if thrust must be added and held to touchdown to salvage a landing, do a balked/rejected landing.
3.9 Ditching / forced landing imminent
Setup
- About 2,000 ft, ~200 kt, over the water on a JFK approach, about 30 nm from the airport. Bird strike, both engines flame out. Start from a freeze with the engines already shut down.
- APU off, so the ADG deploys. ✅ On emergency power the copilot's PFD, MFD, FD 2, VHF COM 2, RTU 2, VHF NAV 2, ATC 2, ADF 2 and RA 2 are lost, along with the AP and yaw damper 2 (QRH 2-8). So the captain flies and the FO runs the checklist (dual credit). ❓ The dual-credit arrangement is from the lesson guide, which isn't in the project.
- Have the QRH pre-opened to the configuration page. ✅ QRH 13-4, "Ditching and Forced Landing Configuration."
- Freeze at about 100 ft above the water. Hitting the water can red-screen the sim or throw the crew around. Then run the Passenger Evacuation checklist.
Brief it like this
- Explain there are two checklists: Ditching or Forced Landing Imminent (today, QRH 13-4; EC Rev 5) vs Planned Ditching (SPOT B, QRH 13-5 to 13-6: Bahamas–ATL from FL210, about 20 min to water ❓). There's also a Planned Forced Landing procedure (QRH 13-7 to 13-8).
- Ask: Time to relight at 2,000 ft with bird damage? No. That would take an APU start or a windmill start.
- ✏️ Corrected speed: the windmill relight requires not less than 250 KIAS, 21,000 ft and below (QRH 1-15; CFM 2-56 envelope: 250 KIAS to VMO, 7.2% N2 minimum).
- 240 KIAS is the Double-Engine Failure memory-item speed (CONT IGNITION ON, airspeed not less than 240 KIAS, monitor for auto relight, pull the ADG if N2 drops below 40%) (QRH 1-12; EC Rev 5).
- So they're going in the water.
- ✅ Ditching configuration (QRH 13-4 table): approach speed VREF; descent rate (if thrust is available) 200–300 fpm; gear retracted for water ("as required" for a land forced landing); flaps 45.
- ✅ Ditching or Forced Landing Imminent steps (QRH 13-4; EC Rev 5):
- L and R PACK switches ........ OFF
- EMER DEPRESS switch ........ Confirm and ON
- Just before contact: EMER DEPRESS ........ Confirm and OFF
- Thrust levers ........ SHUT OFF
- APU, LH ENG and RH ENG FIRE PUSH ........ Confirm and select
- Water (or terrain) ........ Contact with minimum forward speed, but not less than stick shaker speed, and at minimum sink rate
- When the airplane has stopped: APU BOTTLE and both engine BOTTLEs ........ discharge
- Doors and overwing exits ........ Open
- Passenger evacuation ........ Initiate (QRH 13-9)
- (technique) Hold 200 kt initially, then flaps 8 and 20 and fly the approach speed down. In the last ~500 ft, raise the nose to get 200–300 fpm. The whole event takes about 2 minutes. ✅ Supported by the QRH ADG notes (QRH 13-5/13-7):
- On ADG power the slats/flaps run at half speed.
- A momentary ADG power loss can occur at 140 KIAS and below if the flaps are moving, and at 108 KIAS and below if pitch trim is used.
- Below 135 KIAS the AC ESS bus is shed (QRH 2-8; Sys 6-16).
- So getting the flaps moving early, at higher speed, is sound. ⚠️ See Section 7, #10 on VREF vs the 135 KIAS ADG shed.
- FO ditching duties (mostly for the planned version): transmit a MAYDAY; the Coast Guard may help. ✅ Planned Ditching: ATC/transponder notify/7700, ELT ON (QRH 13-5); at ~500 ft, "Radio — transmit final position" (QRH 13-6).
- ✅ Passenger Evacuation (QRH 13-9; EC Rev 5):
- PARKING BRAKE ON
- ATC notify
- EMER DEPRESS ON (if ditching, disregard EMER DEPRESS)
- GND LIFT DUMPING MAN DISARM
- Thrust levers SHUT OFF
- EMER LTS ON
- Evacuation initiate on PA
- APU, LH and RH ENG FIRE PUSH select
- BATTERY MASTER OFF
- Then both pilots: open the appropriate exits, assist and direct passengers, abandon the airplane.
- QS: QSp3 PDF p. 35, Task 9.6.2 Perform Passenger Evacuation: completes the non-normal checklist, exercises emergency authority. ❓ No ditching-specific QS task was found in the QSp captures.
- This is the last event of the session.
4. Debrief
The transcript covers only the pre-brief, so the post-sim debrief isn't recorded. What was briefed about it:
- Debrief in the sim, event by event: freeze, talk through what they'll do, let them fly it, debrief right there, offer a repeat.
- Frame repeats as optional and positive: "Great job. Here's how it could be a little better. Want to run it again? Up to you." Repeats become required only when something is out of standards.
- Final debrief is about 5 minutes: answer questions, then release the crew.
- Use the core competencies as debrief anchors when something stands out (FOM 8-168 to 8-171), especially as preparation for the LOE.
QS anchors to grade against (from the QSp tasks above):
| Event | QS task (QSp PDF page) | The line most worth checking |
|---|---|---|
| UAS | 9.5.2 (QSp3 p. 40) | Announced the discrepancy; verified pitch and thrust for the phase of flight |
| Stall recovery | 9.4.2 (QSp3 p. 44) | Recovery over altitude; no oscillating inputs; secondary warning OK if AoA promptly reduced |
| Full stall / pusher | 9.4.3 (QSp3 p. 43) | Did not counter the pusher |
| Upsets | 9.5.3 / 9.5.4 (QSp3 pp. 38–39) | Stall first; no excessive trim/rudder; within training envelope |
| EGPWS | 9.3.2 (QSp3 p. 47) | FD disregarded; ~3–4°/s pitch rate; intermittent shaker if needed |
| Emergency descent | 9.6.1 (QSp3 p. 36) | Memory items; checklist completed; emergency authority |
| Windshear | 9.1.1 / 9.1.4 (QSp4 pp. 3, 6) | Rotation by 2,000 ft remaining; no config change; ATC notified |
| Contaminated landing | 7.1.3 (QSp4 pp. 28–29) | ±5 kt; touchdown zone; centerline |
| Rejected landing | 7.5.1 (QSp4 p. 17) | ±5 kt; positive rate; config held until above VREF |
| Evacuation | 9.6.2 (QSp3 p. 35) | Checklist complete; emergency authority |
Good debrief questions borrowed from the brief:
- What did you see, and why did you do what you did? (reacting to perceived vs. actual indications)
- Which QRH indication bullets applied? How did you know you were in the right checklist?
- How much thrust did you use, and what did the nose do?
- At what point did you start pulling back, and at what speed?
5. Instructor technique notes
- Ask before you tell. Nearly every topic opens with a question to the FO (what would you do / what does it look like / what numbers would you pick?). Then the instructor adds his own numbers and backs them with QRH data.
- "No right or wrong answers, we're talking as a crew." That framing keeps scenario discussions low-pressure.
- Name the technique as technique. He says outright when something is his recommendation and not published (thrust in stall recovery, the 280 kt high-altitude pull-up, level-off numbers). Do the same. Where a technique bumps into a manual line (ISI vs PFD, riding the shaker in windshear, low-altitude thrust), say both out loud (Section 7).
- Use video for the "why." The UAS video shows a crew reacting to what they believe. Prime the crew before it plays with one thing to watch (the FMA, which will flash amber IAS per Sys 4-32).
- Brief during sim load time. The upset program takes about 30 s to load. Use it for the recovery talk-through.
- Freeze and reverse roles for the QRH 13-10 indications check. It turns a confusing checklist into a discussion.
- Call G out loud during upset recoveries ("2.2… 2.4… 2.5") since the crew can't feel it. The limits are +2.5 g flaps up, +2.0 g flaps down (CFM 2-3).
- Pre-empt sim quirks so they aren't mistaken for errors: FD stuck on in overspeed, the windshear warning during UAS, slow decompression, terrain not showing during the freeze.
- Tell stories that stick: the pusher-off crew, the old ±100 ft stall standard, crews that missed terrain by 50 ft.
- Normalize confusion: "You're going to make errors, and that's OK." Then give one simple priority order.
- Use the PCP/check-airman perspective: say what the check airman looks for (the QSp standards in Section 4, with core comps from FOM Ch. 8) so expectations match before the MV and LOE.
- Pacing: spend most of the time on UAS (~25 min) and stalls (~13 min). Move quickly through simple events (contaminated runway, rejected landing). Skip optional videos except the UAS one, and offer a break around the 1-hour mark.
6. Verify list (manual-checked)
| # | Item (as stated in the brief) | Status | Correct value | Source & page |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | UAS checklist is non-EICAS "Unreliable Airspeed in Flight," QRH 13-10 | ✅ Confirmed | "Unreliable Airspeed In-flight," QRH Ch. 13 Misc. Emergency Procedures, pp. 13-10 to 13-19 | QRH 13-10 |
| 2 | UAS memory items | ✅ Confirmed | AP disconnect; FDs deselect; ISI for pitch; if initial take-off climb or go-around: 10°/TOGA SL–15,000, 5°/CLB above 15,000; clean-up altitude gear up/flaps 0; maintain LSA or higher; respect stall warning/shaker | QRH 13-11; EC Rev 5 |
| 3 | Overspeed protection reverts FMA to IAS at ~VMO–5 after a delay | ✏️ Corrected | In VS or PTCH during descent, reverts to IAS/MACH, bug syncs to VMO/MMO–5, mode flashes amber, clacker. In ALT/ALTS: clacker only, holds altitude. No delay stated. | Sys 4-32 |
| 4 | ADC failure = red IAS, ALT, VS flags | ✅ Confirmed (with nuance) | Red air data flags replace airspeed/altitude/VS when that ADC data is invalid. Separate checklist QRH 11-10, which points to 13-10 if no reliable airspeed side. | Sys 23-17; QRH 11-10 |
| 5 | AHRS → ISI because of ADC–AHRS cross-talk | ✅ Requirement confirmed; reason partly supported | QRH requires the ISI for pitch on AHRS aircraft. Sys says AHRS processing combines ADC data. "Corrupts pitch in a turn" is not stated. | QRH 13-11 (step + Caution 4); Sys 23-24 |
| 6 | FD may not turn off in the overspeed | ❓ Not found | Sim/fleet observation | — |
| 7 | Silencing the clacker early; which control ("DCUs")? | ✅ Confirmed / resolved | AUDIO WARNING switch (DCU 1/DCU 2 DISABLE switch-lights, copilot side console) to DISABLE if the overspeed warning sounds | QRH 13-12 Note 6; Sys 13-18 |
| 8 | Table A, 75,000 lb, FL150–350: ~1°, 70–83% N1; FL250 250–290 kt | ✅ Confirmed (text-layer caveat) | ~1.0° / ~70% (15,000 cruise), ~78% (25,000), ~82% (35,000); 250–290 KIAS range present. Verify on the printed page. | QRH 13-15 |
| 9 | Table E near SL, 75,000 lb: ~1°, ~62% N1 | ✅ Confirmed (text-layer caveat) | ~1.0° / ~61.6% N1; expected speed VREF ±10 | QRH 13-19 |
| 10 | Table B needed above 15,000 ft | ✏️ Corrected | Table B covers climb SL–35,000. The 15,000 ft breakpoint is in the memory items (10°/TOGA vs 5°/CLB). | QRH 13-16; 13-11 |
| 11 | Stick pusher OFF on one side: which? | ✅ Confirmed | Either left or right | QRH 13-11; Sys 9-36 |
| 12 | Pitch-wheel degrees per click; VS button gives pitch mode | ✅ / ✏️ | ½° per click. PTCH is selected by rolling the pitch wheel (FD on, not in GS/VS) or is the default with no other vertical mode. Reselecting an active mode cancels it. VS button engages VS. | Sys 4-19, 4-21, 4-41 |
| 13 | EGPWS and windshear detection unreliable with UAS; sim windshear warning on ILS expected | ✅ Confirmed (first half) / ❓ (sim) | Review: GPWS, windshear detection, flap overspeed, auto pax signs | QRH 13-14 |
| 14 | Stall first indications include continuous ignition | ✅ System behavior / ✏️ CFM wording | CFM first indication = buffet or stick shaker. SPS also activates CONT ignition at high AoA. | CFM 7-123; Sys 9-36, 22-22 |
| 15 | Pusher: warbler + flashing red glareshield stall lights | ✅ Confirmed | STALL switch-lights flash red and a warbler sounds | Sys 9-36; Sys 13-13 |
| 16 | Stall recovery steps; "first indication of increased performance" | ✅ Confirmed | Initiate / continue / complete steps; increased performance = airspeed and altitude | CFM 7-124 (Table 7-31) |
| 17 | No FD for stall recovery; TOGA after recovery OK | ✅ / technique | "Do not use flight director commands during the recovery." Post-recovery TOGA is technique, with no conflict. | CFM 7-123 |
| 18 | Normal descent .74/290 | ✅ Confirmed | Above 10,000 ft: Normal M0.74/290 kt (climb normal is also 290/M0.74) | CFM 7-31; 7-28 |
| 19 | Upset definitions | ✅ Confirmed | >25° nose up, >10° nose down, >45° bank, or airspeed inappropriate within those | CFM 7-92 |
| 20 | G envelope +2.5 / –1.0 | ✅ Confirmed | Flaps up –1.0 to +2.5 g; flaps down 0.0 to +2.0 g | CFM 2-3 |
| 21 | Terrain escape: max thrust, 15°, FD not followed | ✅ Confirmed | Plus: wings level; spoilers retract; continue to shaker/initial buffet if needed; 3–4°/s; no config change | CFM 7-106, 7-107; QSp3 p. 47 (9.3.2) |
| 22 | SLC elevation ~4,200; ILS 17 setup; "Sim 2" slide note | ❓ Not found | Charts and sim script not in project | — |
| 23 | Max differential pressure 8.7 psi | ✅ Confirmed (limitation) | CFM max relief ΔP 8.7 psi. DIFF PRESS warning posts at ≥8.6 psid. | CFM 2-20; Sys 3-21, 3-32 |
| 24 | CABIN ALT caution 8,500 / warning 10,000; aural "CABIN PRESSURE" | ✅ Confirmed | Caution 8,500–9,999; warning >10,000; "CABIN PRESSURE" aural | Sys 3-21, 3-32 |
| 25 | Emergency descent memory items/QRH flow; when masks come off | ✅ Confirmed | EC/QRH steps above; masks "as required" at a safe altitude and at or below 10,000 ft | EC Rev 5; QRH 7-7, 7-8; CFM 7-118, 7-120 |
| 26 | Cabin holding ~14–15k = minor valve issue ("alpha valve") | ✅ Resolved | "Alpha valve" = CPAM. CPAM limited to ~14,250 ±750 → no structural damage; >15,000 → probable pressure-vessel damage. Cabin limiter 14,500 ±500. | CFM 7-119 (Fig. 7-11 note); Sys 3-21, 3-26 |
| 27 | Windshear system active ~10–1,500 ft; nothing on the ground | ✅ Confirmed | 10–1,500 ft RA; runway encounter won't alert | CFM 7-98, 7-100; Sys 16-51 |
| 28 | Past V1: rotate by 2,000 ft remaining even below VR | ✅ Confirmed | No later than 2,000 ft before the end of the runway, even below VR; max thrust | CFM 7-100; QSp4 p. 6 (9.1.1) |
| 29 | Escape: max thrust, follow FD; 15° only if FD inop; pitch to PLI ("AMI"?) | ✅ Confirmed / resolved | Term is AMI (Alpha Margin Indicator) = pitch at shaker onset; FD may command up to the AMI; respect the shaker | CFM 7-98, 7-102, 7-103; Sys 23-37 |
| 30 | RwyCC 3 max crosswind 20 kt | ✅ Confirmed | 20 kt (CRJ-900, Company); RCC 2/1: 15 kt; wet: 27 kt | CFM 2-13; ODH Ch. 10 RCAM page (precedes 10-2) |
| 31 | Rejected landing / low-altitude go-around profile | ✅ Confirmed | GA thrust; landing attitude or slightly higher; hold config until above VREF and climbing; then the go-around procedure | CFM 7-89, 7-77 to 7-79; QSp4 p. 17 (7.5.1) |
| 32 | Forced Landing Imminent: QRH 13-4; VREF, 200–300 fpm, gear up, flaps 45 | ✅ Confirmed | Gear retracted for water, "as required" for land | QRH 13-4; EC Rev 5 |
| 33 | Windmill restart needs ~240 kt | ✏️ Corrected | Windmill relight ≥ 250 KIAS, ≤21,000 ft. 240 KIAS is the Double-Engine Failure memory-item speed. | QRH 1-15, 1-12; CFM 2-56; EC Rev 5 |
| 34 | FO side loses displays on ADG | ✅ Confirmed | Copilot PFD, MFD, FD 2, COM 2, RTU 2, NAV 2, ATC 2, ADF 2, RA 2 not available | QRH 2-8 |
| 35 | Passenger Evacuation checklist flow | ✅ Confirmed | Steps listed in 3.9; disregard EMER DEPRESS if ditching | QRH 13-9; EC Rev 5 |
| 36 | Tow bar slide content | ❓ Not found | Slide deck not in project | — |
| 37 | Core competencies and qual standards in FOM Ch. 8 | ✅ / ✏️ | Core comps: FOM 8-168 to 8-171. Qual standards are in the QSp/SIROS, not the FOM. | FOM 8-168; QSp1–4 |
| 38 | Event order / PF assignments (task 5) | ❓ Not found | Lesson guide and sim script not in project | — |
7. Conflicts & Judgment Calls
| # | Conflict | Sources | Which wins |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ISI vs PFD on AHRS aircraft. Technique: "if ISI and PFD agree, fly the PFD." QRH: for AHRS aircraft the ISI must be used for pitch reference. | Instructor vs QRH 13-11 (step + Caution 4) | QRH. Teach the cross-check as a way to confirm the ISI is sane, but pitch is set on the ISI. |
| 2 | Riding the shaker in windshear. Instructor: pitch up to the AMI and ride in and out of the shaker. CFM: escape guidance goes up to but not beyond the AMI; "Stick shaker must be respected. Reduce pitch as required to stop shaker." (Intermittent-shaker flight is CFM guidance for the EGPWS maneuver, CFM 7-107, not windshear.) | Instructor vs CFM 7-103 | CFM. Say "up to the AMI; if the shaker fires, ease off until it stops." |
| 3 | 15° in windshear. CFM: rotate toward the FD (TO/WS or GA/WS) if available, or an initial 15° if not. QSp 9.1.4 performance statement: rotate toward an initial pitch attitude of 15°. | CFM 7-102 vs QSp4 p. 3 | CFM (the QS itself grades "in accordance with CFM Ch. 7"). Instructor's version matches the CFM. |
| 4 | Turning during terrain escape. Instructor: real world, turn toward flat terrain; "peak ahead, valley aside" is the pilot's call. CFM maneuver: simultaneously roll wings level; no turn provision. | Instructor vs CFM 7-106 | CFM for training and checking. Keep the discussion clearly labeled as airmanship, outside the published maneuver. |
| 5 | "UAS notes never mention those flags." QRH 13-10 Note 2 lists EFIS COMP MON (amber IAS flag) and EFIS COMP INOP (red IAS flag) as no-action messages. QRH 11-10 Note 2 sends ADC failures with no reliable side to 13-10. QSp 9.5.2 includes ADC failure as a UAS contingency. | Instructor vs QRH 13-10, 11-10; QSp3 p. 40 | QRH. The core teaching point stands (red air-data flags = start in ADC Failure 11-10), but don't say the two never overlap. |
| 6 | Low-altitude stall thrust. Technique: less thrust (about the climb detent). CFM: "adequate thrust, as required. If ground contact is imminent use ALL available thrust." | Instructor vs CFM 7-124 | No direct conflict. Keep the technique, but state the CFM ground-contact exception every time. |
| 7 | Stall "first indications" list. The brief includes continuous ignition. CFM lists buffet or stick shaker. Sys confirms CONT ignition activates at the stall-warning AoA. | Instructor vs CFM 7-123; Sys 9-36, 22-22 | CFM for what to recognize and announce. Teach CONT IGNITION as a corroborating cue, not a trigger. |
| 8 | 8.6 vs 8.7 psi. CFM limitation: max relief ΔP 8.7 psi. Sys: DIFF PRESS warning at ≥8.6 psid; safety valves 8.6 ±0.1. | CFM 2-20 vs Sys 3-21, 3-23, 3-32 | Both correct for different things. Teach 8.7 as the limitation and 8.6 as the warning trigger. |
| 9 | Spinning the altitude selector to the bottom. Instructor: acceptable either way. CFM: level at LSA or 10,000, whichever is higher; PM calls 2,000/1,000 above level-off. | Instructor technique vs CFM 7-118, 7-120 | Judgment call. No published prohibition, but setting the actual level-off altitude keeps the ALTS capture. Coach toward it. |
| 10 | Ditching at VREF on ADG. QRH 13-4 says approach at VREF. On emergency power the AC ESS bus sheds below 135 KIAS, and ADG power can drop momentarily at ≤140 KIAS with flaps moving or ≤108 KIAS with pitch trim. | QRH 13-4 vs QRH 2-8, 13-5/13-7 notes; Sys 6-16 | QRH 13-4 governs the configuration. Brief the ADG notes so the crew finishes the flap extension early and expects the AC ESS shed late. |
| 11 | Descending out of the clacker to recover modes/AP. QRH: do not use any FD/AP SPEED mode during UAS. | Instructor technique vs QRH 13-11 Caution 1; Tables B/C | QRH. Descending is fine; recovered modes must be PTCH/VS/HDG, never SPEED. |
| 12 | Upsets "as a memory item." CFM frames the recovery sequence as guidance and options, not memory items. | Instructor vs CFM 7-92 | CFM. Keep the urgency message, but call it "react immediately," not a memory item. |
| 13 | Windshear warning clears "above about 1,500." CFM: removed at 1,550 ft, guidance up to 8 s longer if still in shear. | Instructor vs CFM 7-98 | CFM (minor). |
| 14 | Stall entry altitudes. Brief: below 5,000 ft and FL350. QSp 9.4.3 (OCR): ~5,000 ft AGL and FL300. | Instructor vs QSp3 p. 43 | QSp/sim script. Probably consistent if the QS reads "≥FL300." Confirm in SIROS. |